Etsy sellers, take note: starting September 15, 2024, Etsy is implementing significant changes to its Terms of Use that will impact how disputes are handled. A key change is the enforcement of a stricter arbitration clause that applies to all existing users without the option to opt out.
What’s Changing?
Under the new Terms, existing Etsy users will no longer be able to opt out of the arbitration agreement. Only new users will have the option to opt out, but they must do so within 30 days of first accepting the Terms. This is a shift from the previous policy, where existing users had a window to opt out after any updates to the Terms of Use.
New Arbitration Process
The updated Terms outline two distinct processes for arbitration based on the dispute amount:
- Disputes Under $25,000: Will be resolved through documents-only arbitration. This means there will be no in-person or telephonic hearings, potentially limiting sellers' ability to fully present their cases.
- Disputes $25,000 or More: Will be conducted via videoconference, with no option for an in-person hearing. Previously, parties could request an in-person hearing, subject to the arbitrator's discretion. This change removes that possibility altogether.
Why This Matters for Sellers
These changes are crucial for Etsy sellers to understand because they limit the methods available for dispute resolution. By moving to a more streamlined, less personalized arbitration process, Etsy is removing the chance for sellers to present their cases in person or over the phone, which could impact the outcome of disputes.
Additionally, for those who did not opt out of the arbitration clause in the past, there is no new opportunity to do so now. This could be seen as a disadvantage, particularly since the arbitration process has become more restrictive.
Actionable Steps for Etsy Sellers:
- Review the New Terms: Make sure you are fully aware of the new arbitration rules and how they might impact you.
- Understand Your Rights: Familiarize yourself with the document-based arbitration process and videoconference requirements for larger disputes. This will help you prepare effectively should a dispute arise.
- New Sellers Take Note: If you are a new seller on Etsy, you still have the option to opt out of the arbitration clause, but remember to do so within 30 days of accepting the Terms.
Conclusion
Etsy's new arbitration clause represents a shift towards more controlled dispute resolution, which limits seller flexibility. All sellers should carefully read through the updated Terms of Use and understand these new constraints to better navigate potential disputes with Etsy.